Has Maui gotten too commercial? Is Lanai a secret treasure? Is Oahu tops because of the surfer’s paradise on the North Shore?
Northwest Traveler is starting every week with a new topic in our Monday Survey, and this week Hawaii-loving readers responded with their views on the best islands of aloha.
Now, it’s time for the rest of you to commit. Slather on the Hawaiian Tropic 50SPF (ah, that piña colada scent) and step up to the little grass shack of a voting booth: