Join the informed writers of The Times' editorial board in lively discussions at our blog, Opinion Northwest.
You are viewing the most recent posts on this topic.
October 15, 2013 at 6:50 AM
I watched the Frontline documentary, “League of Denial: The NFL’s Concussion Crisis,” with mixed emotions.
Certainly the behavior of the National Football League toward its players – its employees – was arrogant, despicable, even vulgar.
The league, and the owners and teams it represents, spent years and years denying the occupational health hazards suffered by players. The NFL acted in the same highly calculated and obtuse manner as the tobacco industry: “A problem, what problem? Oh, those things are not about us. And I’m sorry, what do you mean again?”
The documentary focuses on Pittsburgh Steelers legend Mike Webster. The beloved center on Super Bowl teams died at age 50, two years after retiring. He was diagnosed with brain damage in 1999. He had been inducted into the NFL Hall of Fame in 1997.
Webster spent 17 years being slammed into by opponents, and 17 years slamming into others. The tragic toll on his body and mind was terrible. The surprise might be he lasted so many seasons. The failure of the league to acknowledge the hazards and help protect its players is a lethal puzzle. The devastating cumulative effect had to be confronted.
Check out this 2006 report in Slate by Daniel Engber on where the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration had been on professional football.
Where I had trouble making the leap was to assume that football and all contact sports are suspect way, way down into the amateur levels. Terrible things happen. Indeed the Dalai Lama could slip and fall on his way to a peace conference.
Injuries happen in all sports, and that means constant vigilance. Protecting young players – all athletes – has lots of elements: skills and techniques, fitness and conditioning, equipment, officiating, and, I would argue, a sense of honor – a coach-enforced ethic of no cheap shots.
Should kids play sports? Yes, of course. Including football. No sport is without risks. Softball, soccer, cross-country, volleyball and others invite all manner of sprains, injuries, dodgy knees and bruising contact. I think players deflecting a soccer ball on the fly with their heads is crazy.
No competitive sport is safe or easy. Take a step back, mom and dad. Kids quickly decide how much of the wear and tear they are willing to endure to earn a uniform.
I played sports through elementary and high school: Little League baseball, Goldenball basketball, Pop Warner football; high school football, basketball and track. Even college rugby. It was a great experience, give or take a broken arm, a concussion and lots of losing teams.
Professional football markets its violence. Well, whatever sells, I guess. How it treats its players is another matter. The NFL behaves as if it does know the smug, eternal truth about willing, eager athletes: there are always more where they came from.
October 14, 2013 at 6:00 AM
Sorry to bring everyone down from their Sunday Seahawks high, but the question must be asked in light of mounting evidence that football is a dangerous game: Would you let your son play football?
Whether you have a kid or want to answer this hypothetically, here’s a quick poll:
Regardless of your answer, the NFL is here to stay. Americans adore football despite dire warnings from scientists that football has caused long-term brain damage in some players.
- Last week, PBS’s investigative series “Frontline” broadcast a two-hour program on this topic. Here’s a link to a brief, must-see visual interactive explaining how Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy has affected at least 50 players as young as 17. Watch the program below:
- Author and New Yorker writer Malcolm Gladwell wrote a thought-provoking and influential piece in 2009 comparing football to dogfighting. He has not let up on his criticism of the game, as tracked in this August report from The Atlantic.
- On Friday, The New York Times’ editorial page published a fascinating guest column by Gregg Easterbrook, author of “The King of Sports: Football’s Impact on America.” in which he argues President Obama needs to get involved in reforming the game today, just as former President Theodore Roosevelt did in the early, bloody days of football. Easterbrook writes that Roosevelt’s involvement made college football less brutal and led to the creation of the NCAA. (more…)